Did judas go to heaven reddit. But, their actions aren't on even footing.

Did judas go to heaven reddit We do know that Jesus asked his father to forgive them for the crucifixion. Nor did He say that it would be better for Judas not to betray Him; that was a given, a divine prophecy; that wasn't in question. Judas was a disciple up until the very end, but little is said of him in the Bible until… Matthew 7:21-23 (NASB95) 21 “Not everyone who says to Me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ will enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of My Father who is in heaven will enter. The whole "good souls float up to Heaven and the wicked descend into a firey furnace" was invented by Paul, when he realised that Jesus did not keep his promise that not a generation would pass until he returned to install the Kingdom of God, and the doctrine of Heaven and Hell as we know it was concieved by Paul to fudge the issue that, as i Hitler's death reminds me of judas. Welcome to r/atheism, the web's largest atheist forum. My initial short response was that, I find it highly unlikely that Judas is in heaven, but only God knows for sure. Alphonsus—the list could go on and on: Judas is clearly in hell. Because Jesus needed to die for our sins. I don't get your point. He is basically put on trial, and various characters make the case that he should be allowed to go to heaven, but in the end (SPOILER ALERT) he rejects the Lord’s own beckoning to come to heaven. Judas was probably far too ashamed to receive God's grace, possibly by Satanic accusation of what he had done. True, this was in God's plan, but God didn't make Judas do what he did. So, it may seem that Judas was repenting; however, Judas, in hanging himself on the cross, is almost saying to God: "I will not receive your gracious forgiveness to me in Jesus Christ, whom I have betrayed. Mar 3, 2022 · Here we see Jesus condemning Judas, but considering that Judas travelled with Jesus for nearly three years, we know He also gave Judas ample opportunity for salvation and repentance. 21) I don’t have a theological argument, but let me just say— the play “The Last Days of Judas Iscariot” is an excellent meditation on this. Going off CCC 2283, God can provide a means of repentance, and He did to Judas (and the other Apostles). Apr 13, 2022 · We speak of Judas Iscariot, Our Lord’s betrayer. John’s Gospel provides new information about Judas, in spite of being the last New Testament gospel written. And Judas didn’t actually believe in Jesus; he just had proximity to Jesus. Better for him if he had not been born means he will be in hell after the resurrection to judgment: Matthew 26 20 nWhen it was evening, he reclined at table with the twelve. Judas was not saved. Judas' suicide is seen as an act leading to damnation, symbolizing a curse according to Deuteronomy 21:23. The problem is he never repented. And they parted his raiment, and cast lots. 48K subscribers in the OrthodoxChristianity community. Regarding Judas Jesus said that he was “a devil” (John 6:70), and a “son of perdition”—i. But they are not the only people that will go to Heaven. Interpretations of biblical texts regarding Judas' fate vary among scholars and believers, with some suggesting his guilt and remorse might have led to There is good reason to believe that the story of Judas’ betrayal of Jesus did not yet exist at the time of Paul. This may be a silly question, but I had never thought about this before until today. They are chosen by God to be redeemed from the earth. Ultimately his actions did more good for the world and humanity than bad. Sure that's not an explicit repentance like "please forgive me Jesus". The nature of some sins especially those committed by ideology while the Lord can forgive, the sinner can never ask for it. 2 21 And as they were eating, ohe said, “Truly, I say to you, one of you will betray me. There's a possible world where Judas is a saint and a martyr, with some Epistles of his own making up the New Testament, like Ss. Judas knew the Incarnated Word personally and knowingly chose to betray Him, and again this represents the unbelievers and sinners. Muslim scholars have historically neither accepted nor denied the story of Judas, per the Quranic injunction to neither believe nor disbelieve in the stories of the People of the Book. This destiny would not have been fulfilled if Judas didn't sell out Jesus. He did not experience spiritual penitence but only emotional remorse. But he did not as we see here. He's the first one to declare Jesus' innocence. Act 5: 3. Judas died through self condemnation while Jesus was put to death unjustly. People make their own decisions (free will), including Judas. In his foreknowledge, God knew Judas would give himself to be used of Satan. The Church claims Judas, or anyone in fact, to be surely in hell as we would never know the person's last thoughts before he died. St Cleopatra watched St. Jesus didn't say it would have been better for Judas if he hadn't been born. Just like Ananias and Sapphira, whom it was said of them the same thing "Why has Satan filled thine heart?" Best way to know that this doesn't describe a Godly person. Judas would have had to receive Jesus' free gift of eternal life in order to go to heaven. Posted by u/KingBude - 2 votes and 7 comments Feb 19, 2015 · Without a doubt, Judas, the biblical disciple of Jesus, is considered the greatest sinner of all time because of what he did to Jesus. com Judas Iscariot betrayed Jesus Christ and later acknowledged that he had spilled innocent blood and returned the Silver, Judas appeared to have repentance and repented but he mainly repented to himself out of guilt and shame, then hung himself which is self murder. But he can't take it back. God knew Judas' heart and mind, he knew what the Romans and Jews were doing, he could foresee the temptation that would be presented to Judas (despite not forcing it to happen), and he new Judas would Reminds me of the story of St. The true story is larger than what men can understand. 14 votes, 19 comments. Thomas Aquinas, St. If we have free will, we can sin, so Heaven cannot be without sin, and that logic also means it should be possible to get kicked out of Heaven if you piss off YHWH. Regret is a feeling that they could have done something better. That is, suicide is not the issue regarding whether a person goes to heaven. Peter and Paul. I think God wants us to stay living so we can help others. Still all we have to go off of is 4 gospels chosen by someone in Egypt ignoring and Gnostic text and even those four cannot agree on what happened to Judas. If the story is made up, then no harm, because we don’t necessarily believe in it. We should all learn from Judas' grave and damning mistake. This is a question which I've been wondering for some time. So no, Judas did not do the right thing. Getting right with God is the issue. Edit: 2 you don't have to comment. I could only imagine the deep-seated sorrow in Judas' heart when it did not go according to how he thought it would happen. I believe he probably was made afraid to be beaten to death together with Jesus and the Apostles, he didn't really have faith or understand the Word Jesus was bringing, and so he went to the Pharisees and even made an arrangement for some cash on it. " That means it was prophesied beforehand. Jesus calls Judas a devil in John 6. But if that true, why did he go to hell for… In the same token, God didn't force Judas to betray Jesus, but by the time he was told that he would betray Jesus, it was a foregone conclusion. Judas had many opportunities to plead for forgiveness but instead killed himself out of shame for betraying his Lord for some money. 5K subscribers in the god community. St. Problem two. Jesus says of Judas, "The Son of Man will go just as it is written about him, but woe to that man (Judas) by whom the Son of Man is betrayed! It would have been better for that man if he had not been born. It was the devil making him do. By any plain and unbiased reading of these texts, Christ is saying that Judas will not be saved. " This is all of us though. But Judas had missed the point and misunderstood Jesus' message. In Dante’s inferno Judas is in the 9th circle of hell, and although it is not canon, Dante’s inferno has probably influenced Catholic views. But, their actions aren't on even footing. “Is Judas in heaven or hell?” The first response was Jan 29, 2019 · So instances like this. And I know that only Christians can go to heaven but I have a Jewish Freind who I care about and I don’t want him to go to he*l so I’m confused and conflicted and just looking for answers Edit: Its been over 2 years since i posted this im much more educated now. There was no greater example of repentance in the Bible. but we must conclude that he did not go to heaven. All of the facts are the same. Judas had regret for what he did. As surely as Judas lived, he betrayed Christ, just as it was written beforehand, and asserted beforehand by the Savior that he would. Jesus says it would be better for that man never to have been born than to do the things he has done. So I suppose we could multiply many examples from Scripture alone that point to the fact that Judas did not go to heaven, and if he were in purgatory then he would be on his way to Mar 27, 2024 · One of the key events of Holy Week is the betrayal of Jesus by Judas Iscariot—something many Christians are convinced caused Judas to go to hell. e. This was many years ago, but they did a truly awesome job and I got very emotional at the performance of the kid playing Judas. And unlike judas I think hitler couldn't even regret let alone repent. He said "Few will enter heaven". As with satan, Judas' falling is his own fault. Furthermore, we find that Judas was possessed by Satan. repentance is complete U-Turn. Posted by u/Odd_Employment_6890 - 2 votes and 20 comments 2. Varus be martyred, a one way ticket into God's presence because God will not turn away those who refuse to turn aw Open menu Open navigation Go to Reddit Home. Long story short, my friend said that judas was predestined to betray Jesus. Either way Judas had a part he had to play and he did it and then allowed someone to go to hell for something that had to be done by his own design just does not seem right. Samael allegedly sinned while in Heaven, he was kicked out for being too prideful, so that can only mean free will still exists in Heaven. The resurrection of the dead has not yet occurred, nor has the white throne judgement covered in the book of Revelation, chapter 20. It is the heretical Calvinistic belief that God “predestines” certain people to go to hell by purposefully depriving them of grace. So Jesus said only few will go to both Heaven and Purgatory, because if you enter Purgatory, you'll go to Heaven. Jesus referred to the loss of one as the son of destruction. [25] Aug 27, 2024 · No, Judas did not go to heaven. And if judas didn't betray…. Apr 9, 2015 · A person does not go to hell because God predestined. In her view: Since God is all-knowing, and since He knows therefore who will go to Heaven and Hell, who will accept Jesus as their Lord and savior and who wouldn't, that means He knows the kind of person Judas was. r/god is for discussion of all things "God". In Matthew 27:4, Judas says "I have sinned for I have betrayed innocent blood". VI) proved he couldn't be trusted to be fair to his subjects. He is or will be in Hell, then Hell will be cast into the Lake of Fire. Here, Judas was the treasurer for Jesus and the apostles, with John 13:29 referring to him holding “the bag” and tasked with purchasing necessities or distributing alms to the poor. The betrayal could only have been done by Judas. And, as we all know, God does not want to condemn anyone. He felt guilt but he didn't use the power of this shame to drive himself to repentance. Someone left a comment about Judas that I thought should be addressed because of its implications: “Judas did what he had to do. smyup gtti pmfk qpxzg eda hna gikp zoo utxqf tdprn boctm vxwpbo wjwlt hqre mvuvmc