Top rope vs lead climbing reddit. I’d rather be safe then sorry.
Top rope vs lead climbing reddit Does anyone have experience with the Pinch? How does it feel compared to the Grigri? Is it good for lead? Thanks! I have a Mega Jul and a GriGri, and will only use the GriGri for top rope as I dislike the way you have to feed out slack. The rope is usually fed through an anchor system at the summit of the climb and down to the climber. Neither the grigris nor the neox will slip if already locked with a climber hanging on the load strand. No need to switch devices for lowering. The + does have an antipanic feature where you can’t pull the lever all the way back otherwise is auto locks the cam and you have to release the lever and start lowering again so you have to feel out the tension on it more yourself (which can be real annoying Recently within the past two months I have gotten into top rope climbing and I can confidently climbing 5. I'm guesstimating you had about 20 feet of rope out, so four feet of stretch. Once someone is proficient with both an ATC and a GriGri2, I think the case is difficult to make that the ATC is any safer. The home of Climbing on reddit. Something to watch for when getting a rope- double weave ropes are more pliable in the hand and don't twist up as much. I don't really have any experience with the top rope vs lead mode feature so i can't really speak to the potential usefulness. Internally, the rope runs along a cam, which allows the rope to pass if moving slowly but when the rope moves quickly the cam will rotate, pinching the rope. GriGri2 pays out slack very easily when you get the hand positioning right, makes the falls/hanging a lot more comfortable (especially when the belayer is off the ground), prevents rope slip when people are hanging, and lowers very smoothly. 11s. 8 - 5. Vertical ventures. com Jun 2, 2021 · Please post some videos of people who can't even set up a decent top rope doing a great job lead climbing. I know people say just buy any basic, cheap one for starters but I want and am willing to invest on something that I could use for the next couple years. I think it might be because its a lot easier to see progress on the top rope scale because there are more increments up to advanced - 5. The st Pete one is really large and nice with a big lead climbing wall. leash for regular walks. The prevailing assumption has been leading a route outdoor. Keep in mind, however, that this feature is highly dependent on the diameter of the rope being used. 386 votes, 36 comments. As the climber moves up the wall, the rope smoothly slides through a belay device that rests on their harness. Also, look st any international climbing competition. Since you cannot really 'send' on top-rope, I can't see it as anything besides practice. The most obvious example is the rope itself, but there are also harness designs where the belay loop is the same place you tie in for lead climbing. I top rope/ lead 2/week. 11-5. This is true for top-rope climbing, but especially for lead climbing where you need to know and pay attention to way more stuff in terms of safety. Just used mine yesterday for the first time and boy did they feel sticky on slab. Agree with the Veloce. In a top rope situation, what's wrong with attaching the climber to the rope with a locking biner, instead of constantly tying and untying a figure eight follow through? I can see that the system would have an additional point of failure, but if my carabiners are good enough to be used for the anchors, then they are good enough to be used anywhere. I have been climbing for almost 2 years now and I am only now looking to get my rope and if I did that before I really wouldn't know what I would be climbing. What I mean by double weave is when you look closely at the sheath of the rope each individual weave section has 2 parallel strands. As a belayer, you do this by jumping at the exact moment you feel the climber's weight engage the rope. If I know they mostly climb indoor, I tend to assume they mean top rope indoor. Whenever I hear the big no-nos (with regards to clipping) for lead climbing, it's always not to z-clip and to back-clip. Most top rope falls aren't forceful enough for this to be a concern. In the case of a top rope fall you'll swing out from the wall as far a lot further — your anchor is above the lip, this could mean swinging into trees, or rock face. Without modifying your gri-gri, I don't know of any way to get the rope to feed hands-free. It feels natural for top rope belay as well, so I just choose to keep my methods consistent. I really liked the Grigri for top roping. If I’m spending a long day climbing, I will generally use the trick where you put a carabiner with a small nose through the back, and pull on that to lower. The rare individual might lead and top rope the same grade, but in my experience most people will get a clean top rope ascent at least two letter grades harder than they redpoint. it was a pain in the ass to take in slack as i climbed so i switched to butterfly knots on a strand instead of the ropeman (while waiting to buy a micro trax hehe) I feel much more confident bouldering than roping. Dec 27, 2022 · Top rope belaying is managing the rope for someone climbing the top rope from the other side of the rope, thus creating opposition. The Sport Climbing competitions (YouTube it, its really awesome!). As for belaying I would personally top rope on the last climb and top out. It was a great experience. Very sadly, I've known two people who had accidents setting up top ropes. I suppose it's due to the fact that when bouldering, it's just me and the rock. After some warming up, I tried some 6+/7 (I think is like 5. If I know someone climbs outside regularly, I assume they mean their lead grade outdoor. So in many cases you need to feel comfortable lead climbing to get to the first anchor to set a top rope and have your own gear. New to indoor climbing. Top rope is good for linear routes that go primarily straight up and down. Bouldering is the best training for sport climbing if you're a sport climber. ) The initial 25 ft of radically overhanging savergry, precise movement and powerful gymnastic climbing is in my opinion slightly harder than Esperanza V14 but on a rope clipping bolts and then yields a jug followed by solid 5. I wouldn't solo lead with the gri-gri, unless you are talking about aid climbing. The belay point for a top rope can be either anchored to the groud or not (normally is) but for leading the belay point should not be anchored as this gives the climber a softer fall. Every company measures their ropes Hello! I've been climbing for about 2 years now, but over the past 3 months have been going on a regular basis and getting more serious about it. My understanding is: Single: your standard climbing rope. Whereas on top rope/lead there are usually only a few moves where I have to focus on technique. In the gym where I climb they recommend no more than a 30% weight difference for lead climbing and prohibit anything over a 50% weight difference. Ok, I'm having trouble understanding ropes. But when on a rope which is inherently safer, Im literally shitting myself in a roof climb. In lead belaying you're paying out rope (giving slack) while in top rope you're always taking in slack. Some ropes only have 1. Fast clipping makes lead climbing so much easier. I use two strands of rope fo I forgot to link to the Petzl article When top roping I can usually completely a 10d in one try, but outside a 5. Thank you! EDIT: Summary of the responses to me: the difference comes from the added mental exertion in lead climbing, as falls are not a big deal with TR but can still be very dangerous while leading (sport or trad), as well as the fact that you don't have to stop to clip or place gear while TRing, which definitely adds more physical exertion. If yours does not, you should not be climbing there. Leading requires a lot more time and at the gym I don’t know if it helps with headspace at all since the clips are so close together anyway Movement Englewood, Baker, Boulder, and Golden all have top rope and lead climbing. It won't work here, because the rope is going through small chain links that won't fit a bight. Most climbers tie in with the figure-eight follow-through. The best current setup for top rope soloing is a combo of the Trango Vergo and the Microtrax. the ascension ''glides'' really smoothly on the rope as you climb. I boulder clearly under the level i can do in toprope or lead climbing. I have been strictly top rope so far and have gotten up to 5. I often opt to top rope solo both when working out moves on a project but more commonly on easier routes for some climbing milage. 5 isn't better than 9. the static and dynamic elongation percentages are the based on how the rope is loaded (static means load applied when rope is already stretched out like a toprope fall For me at least, I had to focus on technique (still have to) for almost every move on a bouldering problem. And yes we are scared of falling. They have another location in st Pete (maybe 30-40 minutes from the Tampa one. Then just get whatever is on sale, most of the bigger companies all make fine ropes for single pitch stuff and unless you want to ice climb getting a dry treatment is overkill. The Grigri is a more versatile device. It's great to start off with top, it's a good way to learn technique and build confidence but if you're waiting to reach a point where you know 100% you're ready for lead, you might not reach it. I've seen the Edelrid Pinch and love the fact that you can clip it directly to the belay loop. Thank you for the recommendation! I have quite a few friends and family who are not able to lead sport routes but still enjoy climbing so I am often setting up top ropes for them haha. For lead it introduces some risk because you can't give and take rope fast enough but that means nothing for why it's best for top. I can onsight most v3/v4 and do half the v5s after a few tries. By the time you've worn out your first rope you'll know what you want your second rope to do. I’d rather be safe then sorry. I will occasionally lead in the 5. Been climbing for 8 months but went to boulder maybe three or four times. At Planet Granite I'll climb 11d top rope, 11a lead. Honestly, static ropes are not very useful in free rock climbing (mostly for rappelling, fixed lines in aid climbing, etc. Both of my children, who weigh at least 100lbs less than me, can successfully belay me on top rope. All gyms use dynamic ropes for climbing. Just wanted to chime in that no climbing will ever be “risk free”! It’s all about the kind of risk that one is assuming: bouldering has a high risk of decking, but can generally be low consequence if proper measures are taken; top roping has a low risk of decking, but pretty high consequence if things go wrong. Bouldering emphasizes strength and technique. So you must have a good base of climbing strength. You aren't being irresponsible to your climber (they know they weigh more than you) but not all gyms would allow it. This is because the height of the top rope wall is about half of the height of the lead wall, and also because the lead wall has lots of overhangs. Can be used in wide variety of situations My gym actually sets boulders a lot easier and top rope a lot harder. I think the reality is closer to the opposite of that. Reddit's rock climbing training community. With lead climbing you need to have more awareness of your feet. I have been to both and have a membership at Momentum. I also met some 5. But the article covers this well. 12 indoors on top rope. My question is why do I struggle so much when sport climbing compared to bouldering. 8mm and bigger. The other setting up a toprope on 25 foot cliff had a fatal fall. General insight: footwork is everything with lead climbing. 4M subscribers in the climbing community. I've been bouldering for a while now and I've finally decided to try doing some top rope. If you are talking about toproping in the gym vs. The only thing top rope and leading have in common are the moves you have to execute to finish the climb. niycoprafhjiizgttbkurbglvackwuniunyoomtkmhlnmmpbgaqfdgivifzstsvnzzuflkcbzjwqdo